On the afternoon of December 19, 2025, the board of the Kennedy Center voted to put a living president’s name on a dead president’s memorial. By evening, the letters were on the marble. A congresswoman who sits on that board by law tried to speak. They muted her microphone and called the vote unanimous. Chuck Redd, the jazz drummer who had played Christmas Eve at the center for years, saw the new name on the website, then on the building itself. He canceled within hours. Two years of this, in one afternoon: the inheritance retitled behind closed doors, the objection silenced, the musicians out in the cold.
Mass, the piece Jackie commissioned. Nixon stayed home on opening night; he judged it should be the Kennedys’ night, and he came the next evening for the symphony. Italy sent 3,700 tons of Carrara marble in the dead man’s honor. At the groundbreaking, Johnson dug with the same gold-plated spade that broke ground for Lincoln’s memorial in 1914 and Jefferson’s in 1938. Congress keeps the building standing. Tickets and gifts pay for the art. Memorial first. Venue second. Brand never.
The anger that brought the wreckers in was not fake. Arts institutions spent years drifting into faction. Seasons started reading like position papers. The galas, the donor walls, the hundred-dollar seats, the quiet smugness about who the art was for. The country had been handed a target it could see. Grenell called the place too woke and niche. Crude words. Some seasons earned them. The roof did need money, and Congress had already voted roughly $257 million for repairs. The protest cancellations cut both ways.
Marin Alsop stayed and conducted, because music, she said, is no partisan issue. W. Kamau Bell opened his tour in the hall. When the center dropped its own children’s musical, Finn, the decision came before the board changed hands, and it was still read as a purge. The creators answered with a benefit concert in New York. A healthy fight over programming sounds like that: loud, specific, survivable. A commons argues. That noise is the sound of it being alive.
Then came the rescue. Ticket sales collapsed. By August, the internal books showed a projected $23 million deficit for the year, the steepest drop landing after the name went up. Hamilton walked away from its third engagement, a run meant to mark 250 years since the Declaration. Jeffrey Seller, the producer, had played that hall proudly in 2018, with this same president in office. He said some institutions are sacred and should be protected from politics. The college theater festival, wired into schools across the country for nearly sixty years, suspended its affiliation. The Honors, hosted for the first time by a president instead of watched from his box, fell to 3.01 million viewers, the lowest ever. Grenell said he had raised $130 million. The money did not exist. Layoffs started on March 26, 2026, and kept coming.
In May, a federal judge, Christopher Cooper, ruled the name had been installed illegally and ordered it off the building. The board answered with a new plan: carve credit lines into the facade, rename the plaza. On September 15, Cooper barred that too, twenty-two pages and one holding. No new memorials at the Kennedy Center without Congress.
The board voted that same day to close the building. It sits dark now, bleeding staff, while the president poses with a poster that reads Kennedy Center Demolished. One sentence will not leave me: the treatment is killing the patient, and the family suspects the doctor wanted the estate. If the programming drifted, fight the programming. You do not fix a season by renaming a grave.
The ache in all this is that the man being commemorated explained, while he was alive, why the place matters. December 1962, writing in Look magazine, he reached back through Franklin Roosevelt to Lincoln, who kept the Capitol dome rising in the third year of the Civil War. If people see the Capitol going on, Lincoln said, it is a sign we intend this Union to go on. Then Kennedy wrote the sentence they later carved into the center’s own walls: “The life of the arts, far from being an interruption, a distraction, in the life of a nation, is very close to the center of a nation’s purpose, and is a test of the quality of a nation’s civilization.”
Weeks earlier, at the pageant gala, he had called art the great democrat, calling forth genius from every sector of society, disregarding race or religion or wealth or color. And on a raw October morning in 1963, at Amherst, breaking ground for a library named for Frost, twenty-seven days before the motorcade, he said the rest of it. “When power corrupts, poetry cleanses.” “Art is not a form of propaganda; it is a form of truth.” “Artists are not engineers of the soul.”
He looked past his own century: “I look forward to an America which will not be afraid of grace and beauty.” He warned that a nation which disdains art invites the fate of Frost’s hired man, with “nothing to look backward to with pride, and nothing to look forward to with hope.” Then he handed us the sentence that judges us now:
“A nation reveals itself not only by the men it produces but also by the men it honors, the men it remembers.” He wrote the test. We are taking it.
Why did the brothers know the classics well enough to live inside them?
Schooling, yes.
Choate, Harvard, a house where reading was equipment and dinner was an exam. Plenty of men leave Harvard with quotation books and no convictions. The Kennedys read for use. Jack wrote Profiles in Courage flat on his back after spinal surgery; his aides carried part of the load, everyone knows it, and the Pulitzer committee gave him the prize anyway. In October 1962 he pressed Barbara Tuchman’s The Guns of August on his circle and told them why. He would not follow a course that let anyone write a comparable book about those thirteen days. A narrative history held back a war.
His favorite poem was Alan Seeger’s “I Have a Rendezvous with Death,” written by a man who died on the Somme at twenty-eight. Jackie memorized it because he asked her to. She later told friends he recited it on the plane from Fort Worth to Dallas, the last morning of his life. Frost read at the inauguration because the new president wanted a poet there; when the glare off the snow blinded him to his new poem, he recited “The Gift Outright” from memory. Casals had refused for decades to play in any country that recognized Franco. He came out of that exile to play the East Room, because this president asked. Poetry was furniture in the rooms where Jack Kennedy thought.
Robert’s education ran through grief, and it happened where we could watch it. Easter 1964, Antigua. Jackie handed him Edith Hamilton’s The Greek Way. The biographers say he barely left his room. He underlined it, carried it, memorized its Aeschylus: “He who learns must suffer.”
When he resigned as attorney general that September, he closed his farewell with her phrase about taming the savageness of man. When he won his Senate seat that November, he ended the night with Tennyson: “‘Tis not too late to seek a newer world,” a line he later gave to a book as its title.
On the stump he borrowed Shaw, dreaming things that never were and asking why not, the line Ted carried into the eulogy at St. Patrick’s. Then came April 4, 1968. Indianapolis. A flatbed truck in a Black neighborhood, his murdered brother’s overcoat on his shoulders, no notes. He told the crowd Dr. King was dead, and the tape catches the wail that rose. He spoke of his own family’s loss in public for the first time.
Then he said, “My favorite poet was Aeschylus,” and from memory he gave them this: “Even in our sleep, pain which cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart until, in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom through the awful grace of God.”
He asked them to dedicate themselves to what the Greeks had written, to tame the savageness of man and make gentle the life of this world. The part I love: that sentence belongs to no Greek. Edith Hamilton wrote it herself, in her introduction. He had read her book so hard he absorbed the translator with the text. Indianapolis held that night while other cities burned. Two months later he was gone, and the Aeschylus lines are cut into the stone above his grave at Arlington. That is what load-bearing literature looks like. It shows when the weight lands.
I will give you my own evidence, dated. The night of the renaming vote, I put on the Indianapolis tape. I listened to the shriek when he says King is dead, and to the pause before “my favorite poet.”
You can hear him breathe before he reaches for the Greeks, like a man climbing down into a book for something that will hold. I sat there longer than the tape runs. All this September, with the building dark over the river and the lawyers trading rulings, I have been rereading Amherst.
What I feel is closer to homesickness than anger.
I want a country whose leaders argue with poems, whose buildings keep promises to the dead.
I want a man at a podium who can say grace and beauty without bracing for the smirk.
Modest requests: furnished minds, and the courage to quote something older than a poll.
I know the objection. Camelot had a marketing department. The father’s money was real, the machine was real, the cynicism was real. Granted, all of it. Now explain the marked-up book in the Antigua room, read alone, no camera, no constituency. Nobody memorizes Greek tragedy at midnight to win a precinct. The myth belonged to them. The reading belonged to them too, and the reading is the part we get to keep.
The attack lands on all of us, whatever you vote. By law, the building is the one national memorial to Kennedy in Washington. A memorial is a promise the living make to the dead. Retitle it and the promise becomes a trophy, and a country that shrugs at that has told you what its promises are worth.
If you vote Republican, run it backwards. Picture a board seated by a president of the other party, voting to carve its hero’s name across the memorial of a president you love, claiming he saved the place. Feel the revulsion. That feeling is the principle.
Institutions belong to the country or they belong to whoever holds the keys this season. There is no third way. For half a century both parties kept the covenant. The Eisenhower Theater carries a Republican’s name inside a Democrat’s memorial. Reagan sat in the box for Arthur Miller. Clinton sat for Charlton Heston. The argument stayed onstage, where arguments belong. And the place reached past its walls: free performances from half the world, a college festival wired into regional schools, education programs in towns that never bought a ticket. You never had to walk in to be enlarged by it. So an attack on the Kennedy Center is an attack on three things at once: the memory of the dead, the law of the land, the habit of sharing anything at all.
Kennedy said it at Amherst. A nation reveals itself by whom it honors.
Look at what we are revealing.
Leave a ReplyCancel reply