A Cast Is Not an Alibi: Hamilton, 1776, and the Founders of Forty-Sixth Street

I said nothing at the table. We were playwrights of every age and race, talking Broadway and casting in a private room. A friend said Hamilton was “whitewashing history” because its cast of many colors excused an all-white founding. I listened. I rarely talk in rooms like that, since no one learns while talking. The speaker stays unnamed and undescribed because the room was private, and the charge draws fire from two directions. I had seen the original company and loved the craft. I had also carried 1776 with me since childhood. My friend’s charge was not easy to wave away, and I did not try that night. The answer has taken me longer than it should have.

Continue reading → A Cast Is Not an Alibi: Hamilton, 1776, and the Founders of Forty-Sixth Street

Miscast: The Playwright Decides, and No One Else Gets a Vote

There is a moment in the life of every playwright when someone walks into a rehearsal room and announces that the character you wrote is not, in fact, the character you wrote. The director has a vision. The institution has a policy. The casting committee has decided that your Irish Catholic mother from the Southside of Chicago would be better served by an actress who has no connection to the world you built because connection, in the current theatrical climate, is less important than representation, and representation is whatever the people who control the stage say it is. You sit there. You watch your play become someone else’s argument. And you have two choices: you can let it happen, or you can pull the production.

Continue reading → Miscast: The Playwright Decides, and No One Else Gets a Vote

The Ruse of Non-Traditional Casting

Non-traditional casting is a political ruse that needs to end.  If you haven’t heard that term before, “non-traditional casting” is a politically elevated cultural cudgel that argues you can cast any actor of any gender, Race, color or creed, in any role for any reason and the audience will be fine with it because the theatre is colorblind and Race-neutral and culturally sensitive.  It’s all a bunch of hooey.

Continue reading → The Ruse of Non-Traditional Casting

August Wilson Died Tonight

The great American Playwright August Wilson died tonight of liver cancer. His doctors said this Summer in the month that bore his name he might live until October. And so he did. He was 60. Here is the tribute I wrote to him on August 27, 2005. We breathlessly miss him already.