I said nothing at the table. We were playwrights of every age and race, talking Broadway and casting in a private room. A friend said Hamilton was “whitewashing history” because its cast of many colors excused an all-white founding. I listened. I rarely talk in rooms like that, since no one learns while talking. The speaker stays unnamed and undescribed because the room was private, and the charge draws fire from two directions. I had seen the original company and loved the craft. I had also carried 1776 with me since childhood. My friend’s charge was not easy to wave away, and I did not try that night. The answer has taken me longer than it should have.

The same word has been aimed at both shows. In casting talk, whitewashing usually means a white actor playing a role of color. Hamilton moves in the other direction. Lyra D. Monteiro used the word for the history instead, calling it “the same whitewashed version of the founding era” in . The multiracial casting does not rescue it. The Times used the word in 2022 for what people might assume about 1776. I would call my friend’s charge laundering and begin with the facts. Then I would ask how the effect works. Motive should come last, if at all. The Non-Traditional Casting Project’s 1986 definition covered roles for which race has no bearing. Miranda specified non-white principals and a Caucasian King. In , I called that authorial casting and defended it without reservation.
The two musicals opened forty-six years apart in the same house on Forty-Sixth Street. 1776 opened at the 46th Street Theatre on March 16, 1969. Hamilton opened there on August 6, 2015, after the house had become the Richard Rodgers. Miranda called William Daniels from the lip of that stage in March 2016 and said the older show had “paved the way for Hamilton.” Ron Chernow had it with him at the first rehearsal too. He told , that its image “was in the back of my mind.” The East Room joins the shows three times: 1776 played there for Richard Nixon on February 22, 1970; Miranda’s first number drew laughter at its premise on May 12, 2009; the company performed on March 14, 2016. I had worked for , who wrote the first show. Years later, I watched the original company of the second from house seats.
The show that made an East Room audience laugh in 2009 was earning conservative praise by 2015. Monteiro names David Brooks and Peggy Noonan, with Richard Brookhiser added to the early acclaim. President Obama later joked in the East Room that the show was the one thing on which he and Dick Cheney agreed. Then came November 18, 2016. Brandon Victor Dixon read a company statement to the vice president-elect and named “the diverse America.” The next day, the president-elect demanded an apology. NPR credited Miranda and Kail with the statement, written with lead producer Jeffrey Seller and help from the cast. The producers announced on March 5, 2025 that they were cancelling the Kennedy Center run planned for March 3 to April 26, 2026, citing its changed leadership. Six days later, The Daily Signal proposed 1776 in its place. I wrote about that larger break in . During this 250th year, Laurence Maslon counts a dozen professional productions of 1776 and more than 160 community or school ones. Hamilton as of November 2026.
My friend’s charge begins with what Hamilton leaves out of its hero’s record on slavery. Ishmael Reed attacked the musical in CounterPunch on August 21, 2015, without having seen it. I saw the original company within its first three months on Broadway. Monteiro calls it fairly accurate and says its remaining inaccuracies serve the story. Her complaint is selection. Hamilton may have owned no one himself, but he was tied to transactions in enslaved people, including rented labor and purchases for family and friends. Monteiro traces the hero’s glow to Chernow’s biography, which stresses abolitionism and passes over that involvement. Jessie Serfilippi read a cash-book entry of March 23, 1796 as a purchase for Hamilton himself. Michael E. Newton and Philo Hamilton dispute her reading, so the entry cannot settle the point. A third cabinet battle on slavery was written and cut before its release as a demo on the 2016 mixtape. Cast members had already been pointing questioners to that scene. Miranda told Rolling Stone that nobody acted at its end. Daniel Pollack-Pelzner’s 2025 biography gives the same structural judgment: the debate did not advance the story. Ellen Noonan grants that the cut kept his weak record out of sight. Miranda later conceded, “All the criticisms are valid.”
The strongest critics loved the show and still objected. Monteiro reviewed the original production, Annette Gordon-Reed saw it in August 2015, and I saw it within three months. Reed fired first under a title about Black actors dressed as slave traders. Monteiro followed in February 2016. She found the erasure in the script and its slogan. No enslaved or free person of color exists as a character, though every scene offered room for one. The dinner behind “The Room Where It Happens” required servers whom the song leaves out. Jason E. Allen sharpened the charge on March 9. He called Hamilton “a white American cultural narrative disguised as a unifying color-blind narrative.” Casting descendants of enslaved people as founders, he argued, spares the audience racism’s weight and obscures slavery’s place at the origin. ran the thought experiment with white actors and concluded that the casting “excuses the failure to portray black historical figures.” Monteiro’s said the show “obscures the white supremacist origins of our country.” Allen’s sentence is the one I hear in my friend’s charge.
August Wilson had challenged the casting of white stories long before Miranda. He told a Princeton audience on June 26, 1996 that colorblind casting was “an aberrant idea.” He was talking about Black actors placed inside white-authored plays while Black theatres went without power and money for new work. On page 99 of Miscast, I wrote that his vocabulary now serves the opposite purpose in other hands. The comparison has a limit. Wilson was resisting an institution’s choice for another writer’s text. Miranda wrote his casting into his own score, which announces its license from the first bar.
Miranda declared the casting in six words: “America then, told by America now.” Actors’ Equity defended the notices as “authorial intent.” was simpler. Performers should appear as themselves, without paint, and Hamilton passes. Christopher Jackson, its first Washington, said a multicultural cast added context by its presence onstage. Monteiro reads that as a claim of implicit critique. Leslie Odom Jr. said the show made this history his for the first time, and Daveed Diggs spoke of ownership too. Chernow defended the show as a story about an all-white elite and said the young cast approached the Revolution’s spirit. Miranda points to slavery in the third line and to every character’s complicity. Those defenses explain why the casting never felt like concealment to me.
I did not feel Chernow’s alarm. He had opened a rehearsal-room door expecting the founders as he knew them and found a Black and Latino company. Within minutes, he judged the casting inspired. Monteiro quotes the alarm and leaves out the reversal. I carried 1776 into the Richard Rodgers from a living room and a schoolroom, and I never mistook the performers for the men they played. The sound had already told me what sort of evening this was. Monteiro explains it precisely: the King sings white pop through a white actor while the revolutionaries work in racialized forms of hip-hop. Page 104 of Miscast grants that a white actor rapping this material would approach irony or appropriation. The East Room laughed at the premise in 2009. Monteiro also sees the partisan edge: the show celebrates Hamilton and Washington while mocking Jefferson, who remains central. David Waldstreicher names the pattern by which slavery lifts the heroes and lowers Jefferson. Miranda calls hip-hop the music of the Revolution. Reed heard glamour borrowed from enslaved people. Monteiro grants the subversion argument and doubts the country will let it succeed. She reports that about 80 percent of Broadway ticket buyers are white. My house seats put me inside that white audience, so my comfort with the casting is part of the evidence too.
My own book came after those critics, and one sentence in it is wrong. One sentence on page 110 of Miscast needs full quotation. “No one objected that the casting erased the whiteness of the founding fathers, even though the founding fathers’ whiteness is historically significant in ways that are directly relevant to the play’s themes of slavery, immigration, and national identity.” Four named critics within a year make that sentence false. Reed wrote in August 2015, Monteiro in February 2016, Allen in March, and Gordon-Reed in April. Monteiro’s June reply came near the terms my sentence denied. The Times reported the dispute that April, with Gordon-Reed noting how little serious criticism had appeared. I am changing none to few here. I see no evidence of an intention to launder, and Monteiro herself allows for unintended messages. The effect is another matter because it predicts what an audience can miss. Her review ends with twenty thousand public school students being brought to the show. Children were being asked to claim that history too.
My mother introduced me to 1776 when I was five. She taught fourth grade and controlled the big tube set in our Lincoln living room. On Sunday, October 4, 1970, she put on The Ed Sullivan Show. The Broadway company performed scenes from 1776, including “Sit Down, John” and “Molasses to Rum,” according to the episode guide. CBS reached us on KOLN-TV, then the city’s only commercial station and the station where I later reviewed films on air. A videotape machine in a Brownell schoolroom later gave me the film. I was nine or ten by my own count. One part of my Columbia thesis internship later placed me with Peter Stone on The Will Rogers Follies in 1991. Scott Ellis’s revival gave me another meeting at the Gershwin between December 3, 1997 and June 14, 1998. It had moved from a 499-seat house to one of 1,933. I remember admiring the craft while feeling the room was too large for it.
The company that visited our living room had looked like the Congress it played. Page 107 of Miscast gives the reason its Congress was white and male: the Congress in Philadelphia was white and male. In “Molasses to Rum,” Rutledge indicts Northern hypocrisy as well as Southern slavery. Jefferson’s own notes support the charge. He wrote that Northern members “felt a little tender” because their people had carried enslaved Africans for others. His struck clause had accused the King of a “cruel war against human nature itself.” The producers carried both numbers onto Sullivan. This Congress also acted on slavery by striking the clause, and drama needs an act. Miranda cut his own cabinet battle because nobody acted. The audience watches those men preserve their own privilege.
Power had already taken an interest in 1776 before my mother turned it on in our living room. Before the East Room performance on February 22, 1970, the White House asked for cuts, and producer Stuart Ostrow refused to bring less than the whole show. The trouble followed the show into its 1972 film. Director Peter H. Hunt says Nixon asked Jack Warner to drop “Cool, Cool, Considerate Men,” and Warner cut it. The editor preserved the footage, which returned on laserdisc in 1992 and DVD in 2002. TCM records a rival explanation that leaves Nixon out, so the request belongs to Hunt’s account rather than settled fact. My schoolroom tape predated those restorations by years. Whatever its source, it could only have carried Warner’s theatrical version. I never saw that number in the schoolroom.
Stone and Edwards printed a for 1776 that answered the audience’s standing question with a flat yes. The Note begins with things altered and surmised. It continues with things added and deleted before ending with things rearranged. They claim to list them all and insist that none alters the truth of the people or events. “God writes lousy theater,” they explain. The Note admits that no signing took place on July 4 and defends the scene through the Pine-Savage engraving and drama’s need for form. Stone called his tone affectionate irreverence. He also conceded that “the truth and drama aren’t necessarily compatible.” The Note closes by blaming schools for reducing independence to a few cardboard figures. A school had already shown me what they made.
Stone told me about the bell while we were rehearsing The Will Rogers Follies in 1991. We were sitting in the Nederlander on West Forty-first Street during a break, talking about dramatic structure. Tune had refused a rehearsal room and put the company on that empty stage. Stone and his lyricists, Betty Comden and Adolph Green, still called it the Billy Rose, a name retired in 1979. I had been beside Stone from the first day of rehearsing and casting, about two months by my account. Comden and Green sat two rows away; Coleman and his music team were farther off. After the move to the Palace in early March, our conversations thinned as performances became rounds of fixes. Stone called me more of an associate than an assistant and kept no secrets from me. Stone loved 1776 and regarded it as his most personal musical. He gave the bell as his example of drama carried by sound alone, with no picture and no speech. It was, he said, his dramatic stitching, a last-minute addition that he prized as a stroke of genius. Peter H. Hunt and Stephen Sondheim describe other hands at work on the ending, and a festival guide gives the bell to Edwards. Stone’s word is the only evidence I have for the lateness of it.
Stone told me about Denver’s departure from The Will Rogers Follies during those same rehearsals. The title role had been written for him first. He wanted “Lucky Kid” changed to “Lucky Boy.” Stone refused on behalf of three songwriters who had not asked him to speak and did not care about the word. Denver walked out and would not return, and the song was later cut. Stone thought he had protected the songwriters, and the loss still gnawed at him. Adolph Green relived the story for me at the snack table, and Betty Comden told it again beside me in the house. Their fury had moved from Stone to Denver, whose cause they thought petty. They were wistful about what might have been and sure it could not be repaired. When I raised Denver with Coleman once in passing, he answered with a nod I took for dismissal. Stone also told me Denver had Indian blood, as Rogers did. I believed him. The Encyclopedia of the Great Plains instead traces Denver’s paternal family to German Russian colonists, and I have found no reliable source for Stone’s claim. Stone made a similar claim about Tune, and Tune’s own account supports it: he calls himself part Shawnee. Producer Stewart Lane later recalled Stone blaming an actor’s delivery when a joke failed. For my graduation, Stone took me to the Russian Tea Room, where Comden and Green were dining with his agent Sam Cohn. We never shared a room after that spring, though calls and letters followed. The kindness of that lunch was real too.
The bell Stone prized has no documented ringing on July 4 or July 8, 1776, according to the Park Service. George Lippard invented the familiar ringing in 1847. Popular historians repeated his fiction as fact. The Historical Note names Andrew McNair as bell-ringer and says nothing about the sound at the signing. It discloses the invented signing date but leaves the bell unlisted. No individual gains a virtue from that omission. The bell turns the names into a reckoning. McNair tears the calendar and rings it, and the audience understands without a speech.
Another omission in the same script is harder for me: Jefferson’s promise to free the people he held. The Note lists the altered chronology and Martha Jefferson’s invented visit. It does not list that promise. Monticello counts more than 600 people enslaved by Jefferson over his life, with two freed while he lived and five by his will. The struck clause was advocacy as well as accusation, since it charged the King with inciting enslaved people to rise. Removing it spared the men in the room from owning the full meaning of their compromise. Zachary Clary has argued in The Washington Post that 1776 is the more candid of the two shows. His comparison is fair, and the gift still needs marking.
I watched Tommy Tune measure dancers against a wall during The Will Rogers Follies rehearsals in 1991. The Will Rogers Follies: A Life in Revue presented a citizen of the Cherokee Nation through an evening of the Ziegfeld Follies, ordered by Mr. Ziegfeld’s recorded voice. A strip of tape on the Nederlander proscenium carried a line marked five feet ten. Each newcomer gave her height and then stood against it. Anyone within an inch or so could proceed. A plainly short stranger could be sent home as untruthful without dancing. Stone called it the Tommy Wall. I found it fascinating and harsh. Few women stood that tall, so Tune and two staff members flew to Las Vegas for a weekend search. I think one or two dancers returned and made the show. The bar bent for dancers he already prized. Tune himself had once been told he was too tall for a Broadway chorus. Several women who danced in the company stood below it.
Stone rated the women while I sat beside him. The show gave Mr. Ziegfeld a recorded voice that ordered the evening, and a showgirl was billed as his Favorite. Stone wrote that voice. In the seats, he appraised the women to me, saying which would age well and why one “girl” was more attractive. I was newly married and wanted no part in rating them, so I listened. Jeremy Gerard counted sixteen women in the line for and called them “long-legged thoroughbreds all.” Stone had warned screenwriters, “You have sold away your right of approval.” Robert Hapgood’s account of the Guild contract requires producer and playwright to agree on casting. In practice, producers and directors usually prevailed unless the writer was a star. Stone told me those decisions did not touch him. I said nothing then either.
I did not know about the complaint during rehearsals. Nobody at my level was told. Performers Against Racism in Theater and Stage later charged that The Will Rogers Follies had shut Black dancers out of its tryouts, leaving an all-white company at the opening. Its members said they had been urged to audition and then told no Black dancers were wanted. The group counted about sixty minority performers for twenty chorus parts, with none hired. City investigators opened an inquiry, and Actors’ Equity filed a grievance against the producers. Production officials answered that Black dancers had not come. The casting director reported making calls through the Dance Theatre of Harlem and the Alvin Ailey company, as well as other schools. Those accounts conflict, and I have no finding that resolves them. I remember a Black dancer or two on that stage, cast later and perhaps after opening. counted two hired since opening, one a stand-in. That is as far as my memory goes. The show opened three years and three months after Jennifer Jones first danced in the Rockettes’ line. The commissioner’s rule would reach Hamilton too.
Directors eventually used 1776 to make the casting itself part of the prosecution. Garry Hynes’s 2016 Encores! production used modern dress and a mixed company, with a young Black courier in a hoodie at the first act’s curtain. Jeffrey L. Page and Diane Paulus went further in the 2022 Broadway revival. Their multiracial company included female and transgender performers, with nonbinary performers alongside them. Roundabout called it conceptual casting, and the staging placed a slave auction inside “Molasses to Rum.” Jesse Green praised the casting and found the production disappointing. He thought underlined virtue flattened the characters. I had called the device “the excluded performing the excluders” on page 109 of Miscast. That page also says the authors gave no leave. Their estates did permit at least one added line, and that correction belongs here. I did not see it, and that limit matters.
Page and Paulus turned the casting itself into an accusation against the founders. That is the same device Miranda used for reclamation, and it explains why presence alone cannot settle the argument. Jackson said the company’s presence supplied an additional historical context. Monteiro and Allen answered that presence without characters can obscure. If a script leaves people unnamed, the cast cannot supply their histories by itself. Page 234 of Miscast and Gordon-Reed each imagine a white Hamilton. She uses the experiment to expose what casting hides; I use it to locate the choice with the author. The two shows also distribute sympathy differently. Stone called his tone affectionate irreverence, and Miranda praised the older show’s humanity. Waldstreicher’s pattern runs through both: the virtue on slavery goes to whomever the story loves. 1776 gives Adams the fight for the clause and Jefferson the pledge. Hamilton gives its hero abolitionism and gives Jefferson the jokes.
The legal dispute over artistic intent reaches back to the precision dance lines of the 1930s. Lisa Jo Sagolla reports that Russell Markert kept his precision line white for “visual harmony.” Kevin Winkler traces “Favorite Son” to a Markert number in the 1930 film King of Jazz. In December 1991, while The Will Rogers Follies was under inquiry, city commissioner Dennis deLeon said, “There is no defense for selective casting.” A lawyer used the same city law against Hamilton‘s notice in 2016; Equity answered, and no complaint followed. Artistic intent can defend exclusion or inclusion, so I ask what was shown and which way it cut. Hamilton printed its selection in notices and declared it in six words. In 1991, the general manager cited many criteria and named none, while I had watched one criterion at work on a wall.
The question of who was missing has a name: Robert Hemmings. places him there with Jefferson from May 14, 1776. He was fourteen and enslaved, and they lodged in the Graffs’ rented rooms from May 23 to September 3. Monticello names John Wayles as his father, which made him the half-brother of Jefferson’s wife. Miranda’s slogan claims America then for America now. Monteiro answers that America then did look like this cast to anyone who looked “outside of the halls of government.” Hemmings was in those rooms while Jefferson wrote. 1776 adds the wife who never came and omits her half-brother who was there all summer. His deed of manumission is dated December 24, 1794. The 2022 revival put him onstage, silent and unnamed in the script, dressing Jefferson while Jefferson tries the words about equality. Roundabout prints Hemings; I follow Monticello’s Hemmings. His sister Sally receives a matching uncertainty in Hamilton. Gordon-Reed counts her as the show’s one Black character, while Monteiro describes an ensemble woman who mimes her for a few measures. Between them, the musicals put a brother and a sister onstage and leave both without a line. The bell sounds while the names go up.
My friend was partly right. A cast can make a familiar history easier to love. That effect does not prove an intention to launder, and Hamilton‘s casting changes no historical fact. Its license is audible from the first bar and was printed in the notices. My quarrel is with the script. Hamilton receives an abolitionism he did not earn, and the cut cabinet battle removes the moment when nobody acts. 1776 is candid about many alterations until it gives Jefferson a promise to free the people he held and leaves that gift out of the Note. The bell is unlisted, but its invention awards no virtue to any man in the room. I acquit the cast and convict both scripts on the hidden award. A classroom can ask the same questions I have asked here. What did you change? Did you show the change? Which way did it cut? The three-word ruling from page 227 of Miscast
Leave a Reply